Understanding Car Insurance for New Drivers: A Guide

Getting your driver’s licence is a significant milestone. Whether you’re a young driver or getting your licence later in life, sitting in the driver’s seat can bring a new sense of freedom, responsibility, and independence — along with questions. One of the biggest? Auto insurance.

For new drivers in Canada, understanding how auto insurance works, and how to choose the right coverage, may feel overwhelming at first. While it can seem overwhelming, this guide breaks down car insurance for new drivers in straightforward terms, from coverage options to what affects insurance costs, so you can feel confident every time you get behind the wheel.

Key takeaways

• Auto insurance is mandatory in Canada and helps protect you, your vehicle, and everyone else on the road.

• While each province and territory set out its own mandatory requirements, auto insurance in Canada typically includes third-party liability (required by law), collision (covers damage from crashes or rollovers), and comprehensive coverage (covers things like theft, vandalism, and weather-related damage), with optional add-ons available for extra protection.

• Auto insurance pricing varies and is calculated based on many factors, such as the driver’s personal details, driving experience, the vehicle model, and where you live.

• Building driving experience and maintaining a clean driving record could make a difference in insurance premium pricing.

• Driving experience and your driving record can make a difference in insurance premium pricing.

• There are ways to help manage costs, like accredited driving courses, bundling insurance coverage, and looking for available discounts.

• Comparing options and understanding your coverage helps you choose a policy that fits your life as a new driver.

What is car insurance and why is it important?

Car insurance is a type of policy that helps cover the costs if something goes wrong while you’re driving — like an accident, vehicle damage, or theft. In Canada, car insurance is legally required. Driving without it can lead to personal liability due to injury or damages to third party, and/or lawsuits, or consequences, including fines, licence suspension, and having your vehicle impounded.

Depending on your policy, car insurance can help pay for repairs or replacement of your vehicle, along with liability claims if you’re responsible for an accident that causes injury or damage. Without insurance, those costs would come out of pocket — and can add up quickly.

Types of auto insurance coverage

Car insurance isn’t one-size-fits-all. Policies are made up of different types of coverage, each designed to protect you in specific situations. For new drivers, understanding these options can make it easier to compare coverage and know what protection you’re actually paying for.

Third-party liability insurance

Third-party liability insurance (also called liability insurance) helps protect you financially if you injure someone or damage another person’s property or vehicle while driving. It helps cover costs like medical expenses, repair bills, or legal claims made against you after an accident. What it doesn’t do is pay for damage to your vehicle — that’s handled through other types of car insurance.

In Canada, drivers are legally required to carry a minimum amount of third-party liability insurance The exact minimum depends on your province or territory. For example, the required minimum is $200,000 in Ontario and New Brunswick, while the minimum requirement for mandatory auto insurance in Quebec is $50,000 in Civil Liability.

However, most drivers may opt to purchase more than the required minimum coverage to protect themselves in the case of a serious accident. If the cost of an accident is higher than the limit on your policy, you could be liable for paying the difference.

Collision and comprehensive coverage

Collision and comprehensive coverage are types of insurance that help pay for damage to your vehicle. These two are often lumped together, but each one helps protect against different risks.

Collision insurance helps pay for damage to your vehicle caused by a collision with another vehicle or object, or if your vehicle rolls over (also called “upset”). That can include situations like sliding off an icy road and flipping over or hitting a guardrail or pole. If your vehicle is leased or financed, Collision and Comprehensive coverage is often required by the lender or leasing company.

​Comprehensive insurance helps cover damage or loss from things other than collision or upset — like most thefts, vandalism, fire, flying debris, a natural disaster, or other unexpected events.

Optional car insurance coverage

Beyond mandatory coverage, you can add optional coverage to your car insurance policy. These are called endorsements, and they’re meant to give you extra protection in certain situations. Here are some common options:

• • Family Protection endorsement is an optional endorsement that can help if you or eligible family members are injured by a driver who are uninsured, underinsured, or can’t be identified. In those situations, this coverage may allow you to seek compensation through your own policy. Family Protection coverage is not available in every province, but is available in Ontario, Alberta, and Atlantic Canada. Other provinces offer similar coverage through their government insurance.

• • Waiver of depreciation endorsement. If your vehicle is seriously damaged and considered a total loss, this add-on may prevent depreciation from being applied. Instead of receiving what the car was worth at the time of the claim, the settlement may be based on the original purchase price or replacement value – whichever is less.

• • Alternate transportation benefits (known as “Loss of Use”). If your car is being repaired after a covered claim, this coverage may help pay for temporary transportation, such as a rental car, so you’re not left scrambling.

• • Accident Rating Waiver endorsement may help keep your premium from increasing following your first at-fault accident.

• • Comprehensive emergency roadside and driver assistance program can help with emergency roadside issues, like a flat tire, a dead battery, running out of fuel, or being locked out of your car.

Factors that can affect car insurance premiums for new drivers

When calculating a premium for a new driver, insurers typically look at several factors to estimate risk and set pricing. Some of these factors are about the driver, others may be about the type of vehicle and where you live. That’s why rates can vary from one new driver to the next.

Here are some of the key factors that could influence car insurance premiums:

Personal details and driving experience

When calculating insurance rates for new drivers, insurers may look at a mix of basic details and driving experience. Factors like age and gender can come into play — and this is not based on a single individual. Insurers generally use driving data to estimate risk across group characteristics and set pricing. For example, data shows that younger drivers, particularly teenagers, have more accidents on average than older drivers. That’s why the rates are typically higher for young adults.

New drivers — at any age — usually start with higher premiums simply because there isn’t much of a driving history to go on. Over time, as you build claims-free experience and a clean driving record, that information can carry more weight.

The good news is that no single detail decides your rate. How you actually drive and the record you build over time are an important part of the bigger picture.

Vehicle type

It’s not just about who’s driving — the car itself plays a role in how insurance rates are determined. When you’re getting a quote, insurers look closely at the make, model, year, value, and potential repair costs of the vehicle you’re insuring.

Reliable compact cars, sedans, small SUVs, and minivans with good safety features, low theft risk, and affordable repairs are typically the cheapest to insure. Vehicles with good safety features may help you avoid accidents or reduce the severity of damages, leading to lower claim costs, meaning less risk for insurers.

On the opposite end of the spectrum, you’ll find the most expensive vehicles to insure: high-performance cars, luxury cars, large SUVs, and trucks. However, exceptions exist to every trend. Your vehicle’s size and sticker price doesn’t guarantee a high or low insurance premium.

Driving record

Previous accidents, speeding tickets, driving convictions, driver training experience, licence suspensions and how long you’ve had your licence can affect the price of your premiums. In general, the better your record, the lower your premium. However, there are other factors involved that determine the overall premium. Switching insurers doesn’t change your driving history, so your premiums will still reflect any past convictions or insurance claims. 

Location

Where you live can also affect your car insurance premium. Rates are generally higher in urban areas, where traffic volume, accidents, and vehicle theft tend to be more common, and lower in many rural areas where the risks are typically reduced.

How to lower car insurance rates for young drivers

Getting a quote for car insurance for young drivers can be a bit like sticker shock. The upside? As you build a clean driving record, premium may start to come down over time, all other things being equal. In the meantime, there are ways to help manage costs while still keeping the right protection in place.

Choose the right car

Cars with strong safety ratings, less theft risk, and potentially lower repair costs are typically less expensive to insure. On the flipside, high-performance and luxury models typically come with pricier premiums simply because they’re more costly to repair or replace.

Pro tip: Consider getting a quote on different vehicles before you buy a car, as the premium can vary greatly.

Credible sources like the Insurance Bureau of Canada’s How Cars Measure Up and Consumer Reports can be a helpful starting point when comparing safety ratings and reliability.

Take an accredited driving course

Safe driving is a crucial skill – but how do you develop it? Most insurers may offer discounts if a driver completes an accredited driving course. More importantly, these programs focus on building safe, defensive driving skills, like anticipating hazards and maintain safe distances to prevent a head-on collision and navigating icy roads — habits that can stick with a driver for life.

Increase your deductible

Your deductible is the amount you pay out of pocket if you need to make a claim. Choosing a higher deductible may lower your monthly insurance premium, but it also means paying more if an accident happens.

A higher deductible can make sense if you have some savings or an emergency fund to fall back on if you’re involved in an accident. Whereas a lower deductible might be worth paying for if you don’t have enough cash to front costs right away.

Maintain a good driving record

Building a good driving record takes time, but it’s one of the most effective ways to influence insurance costs in the long run. Safe driving habits also help reduce the risk of accidents and injuries — which matters far beyond premiums. A few practical habits can make a real difference and some of the following have legal implications if you don’t obey traffic rules:

• • Limit distractions. Staying focused on the road is key. Using a phone or other devices while driving can increase the risk of collisions. Data from Transport Canada data shows distracted driving contributes to an estimated 22.5 per cent of fatal collisions and 25.5 per cent of serious injury collisions.

• • Obey speed limits. Slowing down can reduce the risk and severity of collisions — for each 1.6 km/hour reduction in speed could reduce collisions by 5 per cent, according to the Ottawa Safety Council. Obeying speed limits also helps avoid costly tickets that can impact your driving record.

• • Avoid impaired or fatigued driving. Driving under the influence of drugs or alcohol, or when overly tired, can increase the risk of a crash. On long journeys, schedule breaks to reduce fatigue and improve concentration. If you’re under the influence of alcohol or drugs, find alternative transport or wait until you’re no longer impaired.

• • Drive for the road conditions. Snowstorms, traffic, other road users, visibility, and construction zones can affect road safety. Giving yourself extra time and space can help reduce risk, especially in poor conditions.

Bundle insurance policies

In some cases, bundling car insurance with property insurance — like tenant or homeowner insurance — can unlock discounts.

Pay your premium upfront and annually

Some insurers may offer the ability to pay your full annual premium upfront instead of in monthly installments, saving you on an additional installment fee surcharge for monthly payments. It can be a hefty amount to come up with once a year — especially for young drivers — so it may not be realistic for everyone.

How much will new driver insurance cost?

There’s no single price tag for new driver insurance in Canada. Costs can vary depending on things like age, gender, location, and the vehicle model.

The best way to understand what insurance might cost in your situation is to get a personalized quote. This car insurance quote tool can help with an estimate.

How to choose the right car insurance policy for new drivers

Choosing first time car insurance can feel like a lot but breaking it down into a few simple steps can help make the decision clearer and hassle-free.

Assess your needs

Start with how you’ll actually use your car and what fits your budget. Things like your vehicle’s value, how often you drive, commute distance, and comfort level with risk can all help shape the amount of coverage you choose for your own policy.

Compare quotes

Insurance rates and coverage options can vary widely. Compare quotes and see how different policies stack up for your situation.

Pro tip: Insurance advisors need to ask you many questions to prepare an accurate quote. Take a few minutes to jot down key dates in your driving history. When did you get your license? How long have you owned your car? Do you have a copy of completing a driver’s ed course?  Have you ever had an accident or driving conviction?

Understand the policy terms and conditions

Before choosing a policy, take some time to look beyond the price and review the details. Understand key terms like:

• • • • Your premium – what you pay

    • Deductible  – what you pay out of pocket if you make a claim

    • Coverage limits – the maximum amount your insurance will pay for a covered loss

    • Exclusions – situations or damages that aren’t covered

Taking a few minutes to read the fine print can ensure your insurance works the way it’s intended.

Look for discounts for new drivers

Keep an eye out for discounts for new drivers, including

• Graduated licensing discounts

• EV/hybrid vehicle discounts

• Theft Recover Device discounts

• Driver education graduate discounts

• Bundled policy discounts

• Alumni association discounts

• Workplace and union-based discounts

Also consider enrolling in a telematics program, such as Aviva Journey. These programs track your driving habits to provide personalized discounts. Many companies provide a discount when you first sign up.

There’s also one discount that drivers, new and experienced, often overlook: Snow tires! Using snow tires in winter may result in a discount on your insurance premiums.

Get expert advice

Unsure about what coverage makes sense for your situation? Speaking with a licensed insurance advisor can help. They can walk you through options, answer questions, and help find a policy that fits your needs as a new driver.

Hit the road with confidence

They say you never forget your first car and getting your driver’s license opens up a whole new level of flexibility — spontaneous plans, fewer rideshares, fun road trips, and everyday convenience. But driving also means new responsibilities, including making sure you have the right car insurance in place. When you understand your coverage and choose a policy that fits your life, you’re setting yourself up to drive with confidence — not crossed fingers.

Do the prep, get covered, and then enjoy the ride. That’s when driving really starts to feel like freedom.

Get Your Free Car Insurance Quote

Take a few minutes to get a competitive auto insurance quote online

Start my Quote

Learn More

Share This Article